Image Modal
For Sale
55 Peconic Ave
55 Peconic Ave
55 Peconic Ave
55 Peconic Ave
55 Peconic Ave
55 Peconic Ave
55 Peconic Ave
55 Peconic Ave
55 Peconic Ave
55 Peconic Ave
55 Peconic Ave
55 Peconic Ave
55 Peconic Ave
55 Peconic Ave
55 Peconic Ave
55 Peconic Ave
55 Peconic Ave
55 Peconic Ave
55 Peconic Ave
55 Peconic Ave

55 Peconic Ave

55 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964

$2,675,000

  • 4 BEDS
  • 3 FULL BATHS

Property Description

Welcome to 55 Peconic Avenue, a bold, newly built statement home completed in 2022 and set on an expansive 1.4-acre parcel in one of Shelter Island's most coveted locations. Designed for true year-round living, this residence captures southwest-facing water views, dramatic light, and a seamless indoor-outdoor lifestyle that today's buyers demand. The main level delivers a clean, open-concept layout flooded with natural light. Living and dining spaces flow effortlessly around a striking raised propane fireplace, anchoring the home with warmth and architectural presence. The kitchen is the heart of it all-sleek, functional, and centered around an oversized island built for gathering, entertaining, and everyday life done right. The southeast wing is dedicated entirely to the primary suite, offering privacy and scale rarely found at this price point. A walk-in dressing room with custom built-ins leads to a spa-caliber bath featuring double vanities, a glass-enclosed shower, private commode room, and direct access to an outdoor shower-because this is Shelter Island, and luxury should feel effortless. On the opposite wing, two generously sized guest bedrooms share a beautifully appointed hall bath, creating a perfect balance of privacy and comfort for family and friends. Downstairs, the partially finished lower level expands the home's versatility with a large bonus room complete with an egress window, walk-in closet, full bath, and ample storage-ideal for overflow guests, media, fitness, or a private retreat. Outside is where this property truly separates itself. A 20' x 40' Gunite pool with integrated spa, shallow lounge shelf, marble accents, and custom tile finish sets the tone for resort-level living. The thoughtfully placed barbecue and entertaining area makes hosting seamless, while a cistern-fed irrigation system supports lush landscaping. A detached 3-car garage at the rear adds valuable storage for vehicles, water toys, or recreational gear. This is not just a house-it's a modern Shelter Island compound moments from beaches, boating, and everything that makes this market so fiercely competitive. Turn-key. Timeless. Impossible to replace.

Overview

Property Type
Other
Location
55 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964
MLS ID
929374
Listing Last Updated

Property Features & Amenities

Interior

Total Bedrooms
4
Full Bathrooms
3

Exterior

Garage Spaces
3.0

Details

Financial

Price
$2,675,000

Request a Tour

Schedule a Tour

Enter a valid email

Thank you for your interest!

Your request for a tour of 55 Peconic Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964 has been received and an agent will reach out shortly

Done

Exclusive Listing Agents

Jack Richardson

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

(631) 278-9549
Erica Lancellotti

Licensed Real Estate Salesperson

SERHANT. Lifestyle Index

Amplifying our listings by providing geo-targeted data insights that matter most.

    Get In Touch

    Erica Lancellotti
    Erica Lancellotti
    Licensed Real Estate Salesperson
    Please enter a valid email.